Digital or Acoustic, How to Choose your Next Piano

Should you buy a digital piano or an acoustic one ? Should you choose a new or used instrument? Rent or buy? An upright or a grand piano?

Digital Piano vs Acoustic Piano

A digital piano is an instrument where the strings and hammers of a traditional acoustic piano are replaced by sound samples. An electronic system reproduces these samples when the keys are played.

Buying a digital upright piano: a non-portable model with three attached pedals
A non-portable console digital piano with three attached pedals, ideal for an experience close to that of an acoustic piano.

The Advantages of a Digital Piano

  • The price of a digital instrument is significantly lower than that of a quality acoustic upright piano.
  • Even the heaviest models are far lighter and more compact than a traditional piano. Portable models can weigh as little as 30-35 lbs.
  • You can plug in headphones and play at any hour without disturbing your neighbors. In fact, many professional pianists buy a digital instrument as a second piano for this very reason.
  • The MIDI (Musical Instrument Digital Interface) allows you to connect the digital piano to a computer to record your playing, compose music for piano or other instruments, improvise, and more.
  • It does not require regular tuning (at least once a year) from a piano tuner.
  • Digital instruments usually include several sound banks, allowing them to simulate various types of pianos, as well as organs, harpsichords, and electric pianos.

The Disadvantages of a Digital Piano

  • The richness of its sound colors, due to its production method (recorded sounds played through speakers), still cannot compete with that of a quality acoustic piano.
  • Its lightness can become a drawback when the instrument starts to shake or move. This happens when the pianist needs to play chords, octaves, or other passages forte. Some digital pianos weighing over 200 lbs do not have this issue.
  • The single pedal included with portable digital pianos is connected by a simple wire. As a result, it constantly moves around and can even slide away on slippery surfaces (this problem only affects portable keyboards).
  • For a child, learning to play the piano exclusively on a digital instrument is not ideal.
  • If the power goes out, so does the sound!

Can I Learn to Play Piano with a Digital One?

The digital piano has made incredible progress in recent years, both in sound quality and key action (some models now faithfully replicate the touch of an acoustic piano).

Considering a digital piano to learn on is no longer taboo.

Much cheaper and lighter than an acoustic piano—with some portable models weighing less than 35 pounds—the digital piano allows you to play and learn with headphones at any time of day or night.

While it’s possible to install silent systems on acoustic pianos, they are expensive and can sometimes alter the feel of the keyboard.

Furthermore, a digital piano doesn’t require the annual, costly visit from a piano tuner.

When choosing between a good digital piano and a very cheap acoustic piano, the digital is often the better choice.

However, it is strongly advised not to learn to play exclusively on a digital piano. It’s essential to also have regular access to an acoustic piano to develop a proper feel for its sound quality and touch.

Buying a low-end digital piano, or worse, a synthesizer, should be avoided at all costs. The poor sound quality and keyboard feel have nothing in common with a real piano.

If you later purchase an acoustic piano, the digital can always be kept as a second instrument for practicing without disturbing others.

Digital Piano Prices (US Market)

Need payment options? Learn about solutions below.

Entry-Level (Beginners / Casual Use): $500 

Mid-Range (Serious Hobbyists / Enhanced Playing Experience): $750 to $1,500

Upper Mid-Range (Advanced Hobbyists / Near-Professional Experience): $1,500 to $2,500

  • Highly responsive hammer-action keyboard (3–4 sensors, escapement simulation).
  • Enhanced amplification, richer piano sounds, and often a furniture-style stand with 3 pedals included or optional.
  • Examples: Kawai ES920 (~$1,949), Casio PX-S6000 (~$1,850), Yamaha P-515 (~$2,000), Roland HP702 (~$2,000), Korg G1 Air (~$2,500).

High-End (Discerning Pianists/Professional Experience): $3,000 to $4,000+

  • Highly realistic keyboard (wooden keys, counterweights, etc.), powerful and immersive amplification.
  • Sampling from prestigious concert grand pianos, physical modeling of resonance.
  • Examples: Kawai CA401 (~$3,199), Yamaha CLP-835 (~$3,599), Roland LX-5 (~$4,000), Casio Celviano AP-750 (~$4,000).

Hybrids (Acoustic Alternative): $17,549 to $19,600+

Unlike standard digital pianos, hybrids incorporate genuine wooden keys with a full grand-piano-style action or hammer mechanism, which accurately replicates the subtle resistance and movement that a player expects. This authentic action is paired with advanced digital sound modeling and high-quality speakers, offering the closest possible approximation of an acoustic piano experience with all the advantages and possibilities of a digital piano.

The Acoustic Piano

The acoustic piano is a musical instrument with struck strings.

These pianist mice have chosen to record Happy Birthday to You on a prestigious acoustic piano!

When you press a key, a small, felt-covered hammer strikes one or more strings that are stretched under high tension on a cast-iron frame—a massive metal structure designed to withstand several tons of pressure.

These strings vibrate and transmit the sound wave through a wooden piece called the bridge to the soundboard. The soundboard is a large, thin wooden membrane (usually spruce) located behind or beneath the strings. It acts as a natural amplifier: by vibrating, it sets a large volume of air in motion and projects the powerful, rich sound of the acoustic piano.

This purely mechanical system produces a rich and vibrant tone that is impossible to fully replicate with a digital instrument. This is why many musicians prefer to buy an acoustic piano.

How an Acoustic Piano Works

Each key on the keyboard is connected to a complex mechanism. Depending on how hard you press the key, the sound will be louder or softer, more or less expressive. This allows the pianist to play with a wide range of dynamics, from the softest touch to the most powerful.

This sensitivity to touch is one of the greatest advantages of an acoustic piano, offering immense freedom of interpretation.

Maintenance and Authenticity

Choosing an acoustic piano over a digital one means having it tuned at least once a year, which is a significant expense. You also need to monitor the room’s humidity, as fluctuations can damage the wood or cause the instrument to go out of tune.

In return, you get a natural sound, a precise touch, and a real physical connection between the pianist and the instrument. This is what makes the acoustic piano the preferred choice for an authentic and expressive musical practice.

Buying a good quality acoustic upright is a significant investment. But if your budget—and your neighbors!—allow it, it is preferable to a digital piano.

Upright Piano

Unlike its majestic cousin, the grand piano, the upright piano is characterized by its vertical structure. The strings and soundboard—the large wooden panel that amplifies the sound—are positioned perpendicular to the floor. This ingenious design allows it to take up much less space, making it ideal for apartments and modern living areas.

The upright piano, sometimes called a vertical piano, comes in various heights, but the differences between a small model and a tall one are not nearly as pronounced as they are among grand pianos.

BLACK KEYS – Everything you want to know.

Grand Piano

The grand piano’s horizontal layout allows for longer strings and a more responsive action (the hammers’ return is aided by gravity), resulting in greater sound power, better dynamics, and superior tonal richness.

This is why it is favored in concert halls, for professional use, and even in many music conservatories.

Buying an expensive and bulky grand piano is rarely a consideration for a beginner. However, if price is no object and you have the necessary space, there is no downside to starting your piano studies on a grand piano—quite the contrary.

Acoustic Upright Piano Prices (US Suggested Maximum Price – SMP)

Need payment options? Learn about solutions below.

 

Entry-Level (Student or Compact Piano): $5,000 to $9,000

  • Models made in Asia (China, Indonesia), offering good quality for beginners.
  • Smaller size, limited but sufficient tone for the first few years of study.
  • Standard brand-proprietary action.
  • Examples: Pearl River EU110 (~$5,495), Feurich 115 (~$7,160), Yamaha B1 (~$5,699)

Mid-Range (Family / Intermediate Player): $9,000 to $18,000

  • Refined finish, more precise action, better sound projection.
  • Suited for regular practice, often made in Japan, Indonesia (higher-end models), or Europe (Poland, Czech Republic).
  • Quality proprietary or standard Renner action.
  • Examples: Yamaha B3 (~$8,099), Kawai K-300 (~$12,095), Wilhelm Schimmel W114 (~$15,142)

High-End (Intensive Study or Semi-Professional Use): $15,000 to $35,000

  • Excellent tone, balance, and power, with a very precise touch.
  • Japanese or German manufacturing with high-quality components.
  • High-end actions (Renner or top-tier proprietary).
  • Examples: Kawai K-500 (~$16,995), Yamaha U1 (~$14,499), Schimmel C121 Tradition (~$27,100)

Prestige (Concert-Level or Highest Demands): $40,000 to $80,000+

  • Tone comparable to a grand piano, exceptional tuning stability, and tonal finesse.
  • Handcrafted in Germany or Austria without compromise (often customizable).
  • Ultra-high-precision actions, often custom or modified (Renner Premium, specific Steingraeber actions, etc.).
  • Examples: C. Bechstein Residence R118 (~$40,200), C. Bechstein Concert 8 (~$77,900), Steingraeber & Söhne 130 (~$66,610)

Acoustic Grand Piano Prices (US Suggested Maximum Price – SMP)

Need payment options? Learn about solutions below.

Grand piano with Lang Lang playing Für Elise – YouTube thumbnail
Lang Lang plays Beethoven’s Für Elise on a Steinway & Sons grand piano

Baby Grands & Small Grands (Up to 5′ 8″)

Entry-Level: $15,000 to $25,000

  • Length: 4’11” – 5’4″. Often called “baby grands.”
  • Indonesian or Chinese manufacturing. Good sound quality for home use and for starting on a grand piano.
  • Examples: Yamaha GB1K (5’0″, ~$15,499), Kawai GL-10 (5’0″, ~$16,895), Feurich 162 “Dynamic I” (5’4″, ~$18,780)

Mid-Range: $25,000 to $50,000

  • Length: 5’3″ – 5’9″.
  • Japanese or European manufacturing (entry-level German/Czech). Significantly superior sound and action.
  • Examples: Yamaha C1X (5’3″, ~$32,999), Kawai GX-1 (5’5″, ~$33,895), W. Hoffmann T 161 (5’3″, ~$37,900)

High-End: $50,000 to $90,000

Prestige: $90,000 to $130,000+

Parlor & Living Room Grands (approx. 5’9″ to 6’6″)

Mid-Range: $35,000 to $60,000

  • Length: 5’8″ – 6’2″.
  • The standard for conservatories and discerning amateurs, offering an excellent balance of size and power. Mostly Japanese manufacturing.
  • Examples: Yamaha C2X (5’8″, ~$37,499), Kawai GX-2 (5’11”, ~$40,495), Boston GP193  (6’4″, ~$48,999)

High-End: $65,000 to $90,000

Prestige: $120,000 to $160,000+

  • Length: 5’11” – 6’7″.
  • Absolute excellence for soloists and recording studios. Handcrafted by the greatest manufacturers.
  • Examples: Steinway & Sons O-180 (5’11”, ~$110,600), Bösendorfer 200VC (6’7″, ~$177,999), Fazioli F183 (6’0″, $152.600)

Semi-Concert Grands (approx. 6’10” to 7’6″)

High-End: $60,000 to $130,000

  • Length: 6’10” – 7’2″.
  • More powerful than parlor grands. Primarily high-end Japanese and German brands.
  • Examples: Yamaha C6X (7’0″, ~$79,499), Kawai GX-6 (7’0″, ~$69,895), Schimmel K219 Tradition (7’2″, ~$127,808)

Prestige: $140,000 to $200,000+

Concert Grands (9′ and up)

Prestige: $190,000 to $250,000+

  • Length: 9’0″ – 10’2″.
  • The pinnacle of piano manufacturing. These instruments are reserved for the world’s greatest concert halls and international competitions.
  • Examples: Yamaha CFX (9’0″, ~$199,999), Steinway & Sons D-274 (9’0″, ~$217,300), Bösendorfer 280VC (9’2″, ~$269,999), Fazioli F278 (9’2″,  ~$269.700)

Acoustic Piano Manufacturers (Selective List):

Buying a New or Used Acoustic Piano

The purchase price of a new acoustic upright piano depends on its size and, even more so, its brand. The price of an upright from a prestige brand like Steinway & Sons, Bösendorfer, or C. Bechstein can sometimes exceed that of grand pianos from less renowned brands.

Because of this, the used piano market is very active, for both uprights and grands.

You can buy and sell a used piano privately between individuals, but there are also piano dealers who specialize in pre-owned instruments.

If you decide to sell it later, a well-maintained and regularly tuned used piano will depreciate less than a new one.

However, choosing a good used piano can be very tricky. Some pianos that have been refurbished and appear to be in good condition can deteriorate quickly after a few months.

An 1835 Érard piano with Vernis Martin finish, from the Château de Bizy collection. It's not a new piano, but to call this instrument 'used' feels like an understatement... Photography: Teofilo.
An 1835 Érard piano with Vernis Martin finish, from the Château de Bizy collection. It’s not a new piano, but to call this instrument ‘used’ feels like an understatement… Photography: Teofilo.

💰 How to Finance Your Piano Purchase

Buying a high-quality digital or acoustic piano represents a significant financial investment. Exploring various financing solutions can help make this purchase more accessible. Here are the main options to consider for your piano financing.

Personal Loan Options

A Personal Loan from a bank or online lender offers considerable flexibility. These unsecured loans don’t require using the piano as collateral. When evaluating personal loans, pay close attention to the Annual Percentage Rate (APR) which represents the total borrowing cost. Compare fixed-rate loans with stable monthly payments against variable-rate options that might offer lower initial rates. Typical loan terms range from 24 to 60 months, and most lenders will perform a credit check during application.

Retailer Financing Programs

Many music retailers provide special Financing Programs through partner financial institutions. These often feature promotional offers like deferred interest, commonly presented as “0% APR for 12 months.” However, understand that if the balance isn’t paid in full by the promotional end date, interest may be charged retroactively. Always review the minimum monthly payment requirements and read all terms carefully before committing.

Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC)

For homeowners, a HELOC can be an attractive option as a secured loan backed by your home equity. These typically offer lower interest rates compared to unsecured alternatives. The flexible line of credit structure allows you to borrow as needed, and the interest paid may be tax-deductible in some situations. Consult with a tax professional to understand potential interest deduction benefits.

Lease and Rent-to-Own Agreements

Rent-to-Own and Leasing programs provide alternative pathways to piano ownership. These arrangements involve regular rental payments with the possibility of ownership through a buyout option at the lease agreement’s conclusion. This approach can be particularly suitable for students or those wanting to test an instrument before full commitment. Review all contract terms to understand the total cost and purchase conditions.

Before selecting any financing method, compare all terms carefully, consider your budget for monthly payments, and read the complete agreement details. The right financing choice can make your piano ownership dream a reality while maintaining financial stability.

Reading Piano Notes: Videos and Color Notes

Do you want to learn how to read right-hand notes in the Treble Clef and left-hand notes in the Bass Clef? Follow the links for each hand !

Digital and Acoustic Pianos : FAQ

What is the difference between a digital piano and a keyboard?

The terms are often used interchangeably, but they are designed for different purposes. Digital Pianos are built to emulate the sound and feel of an acoustic piano. They feature 88 fully weighted, hammer-action keys to mimic the resistance of an acoustic piano’s mechanism and use high-quality sampled sounds for a realistic tone.

Keyboards are typically more focused on versatility and portability. They often have 61 or 76 non-weighted or semi-weighted keys, hundreds of synthesized sounds, and automatic accompaniment features.

What is the single most important technical specification to look for when buying a digital piano?

The most critical specification is the key action. Look for a “fully weighted hammer action” keyboard, which provides resistance and feel closely mimicking the mechanical system of a traditional acoustic piano. This is essential for developing proper finger strength and expressive technique.

What is polyphony in a digital piano and why does it matter?

Polyphony is the maximum number of notes (or voices) a digital piano can sound at the same time.

It matters because complex playing styles—like using the sustain pedal, layering two sounds (Dual Mode), or playing thick chords quickly—can rapidly use up voices. A low polyphony count can cause older notes to be suddenly cut off or «stolen» when new notes are played, leading to an unnatural or incomplete performance.

While 64 voices is sufficient for a beginner pianist, 128 and sometimes even 256 voices are recommended for a rich, realistic sound in complex musical passages, especially for classical music.

What is the average annual maintenance cost for a standard acoustic upright piano?

Acoustic pianos generally require professional tuning at least once a year. Depending on your location and the piano’s condition, the cost typically ranges from $100 to $200 per session. Additional costs can arise from regulating the action or maintaining stable humidity levels in the room.

How does an acoustic piano’s action fundamentally differ from a grand piano’s action?

The primary difference lies in the hammer return mechanism. In a grand piano, the hammer reset relies on gravity, allowing for very fast, reliable note repetition. In an upright piano, the hammer is returned to its resting position by springs or straps, making rapid playing (like fast trills) slightly less responsive than on a grand.

Does a quality acoustic piano hold its resale value better than a high-end digital piano?

Yes. A well-maintained acoustic piano from a reputable manufacturer can maintain its value remarkably well, often depreciating less than 20-30% over several decades. Digital pianos, being electronic, typically depreciate faster as new models with superior technology and features are released annually.

Is it possible to install a “silent system” on an existing acoustic piano, and is it a worthwhile investment?

Yes, many technicians can retrofit a silent system. This system allows the hammer to strike a soft stopper instead of the strings, while sensors digitally capture the key movement for headphone output. It is a worthwhile investment if you need the authentic touch of an acoustic piano but require the flexibility of practicing silently.

Beyond MIDI, what are other key connectivity features I should look for in a modern digital piano?

Look for USB-to-Host (for connecting to a computer for recording/lessons) and Bluetooth audio/MIDI connectivity. Bluetooth allows you to stream music from a device through the piano’s speakers or use the piano as a MIDI controller wirelessly with music learning apps.